After a year and a half in our home, the exterior finally looks the way we imagined. Starting with a new yard and settling into a different style of home comes with a steep learning curve, but we’re thrilled with the results.
Surprisingly to some, we did not paint the red brick. I’ve grown to love the warmth and character of the original red brick; although painted white brick can be stunning, we decided to keep ours as-is.
When we first moved in about 18 months ago, our Cape Cod-style house had yellow trim and hunter green shutters—a very 1990s palette. While I do like green, the shutter color felt heavy, and the yellow trim was never my favorite.

Other than the paint colors, I loved the architecture: the grand brick steps, the functional shutters, and the two dormers upstairs give the house classic curb appeal. The lawn had been lush at times, but the landscaping was overgrown in spots—something we planned to address.
During our first summer in the house we hired a lawn company to manage weeds, but unfortunately they ended up killing much of the front yard grass. It was disheartening to pull into the driveway and see a brown, burned-looking lawn. We knew we needed a spring reset.

I set a goal to get quotes and choose paint colors by the end of April. The painting actually finished by the end of April, which felt like a real win. I originally planned to use Benjamin Moore’s Simply White for the trim and Graphite for the shutters and door, and I stuck close to that plan with a few adjustments.
What Type of Paint to Use
Our painter asked us to provide the paint, which ensured we’d get exactly the colors and quality we wanted. I didn’t want to cut corners—cheap paint can require more coats and still perform poorly over time—so I chose reputable brands.
For the white trim I selected Valspar Duramax Exterior Paint in a satin finish from a home improvement store. It applied smoothly and offered good coverage. For the shutters and front door I opted for Benjamin Moore Regal Select Exterior in a Soft Gloss finish, purchased at a local decorating store to ensure accurate color matching. The Soft Gloss sits between satin and high gloss, offering durability with a subtle sheen.
Investing in quality paint made sense: it reduced the number of coats needed and should help the finish last longer, particularly on exterior surfaces exposed to sun and weather.
Is There Any Prep Before Painting the Exterior: Trim and Shutters?
Our painter said a full pressure wash wasn’t required; they planned to wipe away dirt and cobwebs as they worked. Still, I wanted to be thorough, so I pressure washed the house and the brick stairs before painting. Cleaning surface grime and mildew helps primer and paint adhere better and contributes to a longer-lasting finish.
The After
Ready for the reveal? I’m in love with the transformation.

Not only did we repaint the trim and shutters, we also replaced the front lawn with fresh sod around the same time. The new green lawn plus the crisp painted trim and shutters made a dramatic improvement, bringing the house back to life.
For reference, here’s the earlier photo again so you can compare the before and after.

The sod is still settling in and filling out, so the lawn will look even better as it establishes. We also hired a landscaper to trim back overgrown shrubs and tidy the beds—especially a large loropetalum that was encroaching on the walkway. It’s been cut back significantly and will regrow in a more controlled shape.

Pressure washing the brick steps and iron railing refreshed the entryway, and the black front door now ties the look together. I may one day replace the door with a natural wood option, but for now the black finish complements the red brick beautifully.

I’ve begun a small front-porch refresh with some accessories that are arriving gradually. The American flag is already up for Memorial Day and July 4th, and it adds a cheerful, welcoming touch.

New Orleans-style lantern, classic planters, faux boxwood topiaries, American flag, and a monogrammed front-door mat are some of the items I’ve chosen to finish the look.
The Paint Colors I Used
Choosing exterior paint colors can be trickier than interior ones because natural light changes how colors read. For the trim, I used Benjamin Moore’s Simply White—my go-to white—because it reads as a warm, creamy white that pairs well with red brick without feeling stark.
For the shutters and door I experimented with several dark shades. I tried a sample of Graphite but found it too medium-toned for my taste. After comparing swatches and sample matches, I settled on Benjamin Moore’s Onyx. Once painted, it reads almost black on the shutters and door, which is exactly the bold contrast I wanted.

The final look—red brick with crisp white trim and deep black shutters and door—brings the whole façade together. It makes me smile every time I pull into the driveway.

Would you have painted the brick white, or do you prefer a classic red brick exterior? I’d love to hear your thoughts and answer any questions you have in the comments.
More Posts You Will Love:
- 5 Easy Steps to Stain an Outdoor Structure
- How to Paint a Wood Fence the Fast and Easy Way!
- How to Plant Flowers in a Pot, Planter or Container
- DIY Fire Pit Area with Pea Gravel
- How to Paint a Concrete Patio












